Recent News

Both instruments are accordions. They have the same bellows, usually the same left hand, and they make the same sound. The whole argument is about the right hand, and about one feature that most comparisons skip entirely.

The Short Version

A piano accordion has piano keys for the right hand. A button accordion has buttons. If that were the end of it there would be nothing to decide.

The part that actually matters is that “button accordion” covers two different instruments. One of them plays the same note whichever way the bellows are moving. The other plays a different note on the push than on the pull. Choosing between a piano accordion and a button accordion without knowing which kind of button accordion you mean is how people end up with the wrong instrument.

The Left Hand Is Usually Identical

Before the differences, the thing they share. Most accordions of both kinds use the Stradella bass system on the left: a grid of buttons where the columns run around the circle of fifths, and the rows give you a counterbass, a fundamental bass, then major, minor, seventh and diminished chords. The American Accordionists’ Association guide for composers sets out the same grid and calls it the Stradella or 120 bass button system.

One button, one chord. That is the same whether your right hand has keys or buttons, and it is the reason an accordionist can move between the two types without relearning the accompaniment. A full size instrument carries 120 bass buttons. Smaller instruments cut the number of columns rather than the idea, which is how you get 12, 24, 48, 72 and 96 bass models.

Some instruments use free bass instead, where the left hand plays single notes across a full range rather than preset chords, which is how Hohner describes its own free bass models. That is a separate decision from keys against buttons, and it exists on both types.

If the left hand side of this is new, the notation for it is covered in our article on reading accordion sheet music, because the bass staff on accordion music is not doing what a pianist expects.

Two Kinds of Button Accordion

This is the distinction to get straight first, because the two are further apart from each other than either is from a piano accordion.

Chromatic Button Accordion

The chromatic button accordion, often shortened to CBA, has three to five rows of buttons giving every note of the chromatic scale. It is unisonoric, meaning each button sounds the same note whether you are pushing the bellows in or pulling them out. Hohner’s accordion catalog puts it in one line: chromatic accordions produce the same sound whether you push or pull. In that respect it behaves exactly like a piano accordion.

There are two main layouts, usually called the C system and the B system. They are mirror images of one another in how the notes ascend across the rows. Both are in regular use and neither is a beginner or advanced version of the other. Hohner sells its Varia One button model as a C system or a B system build of the same instrument.

Diatonic Button Accordion

The diatonic button accordion, also called a melodeon or a button box, is bisonoric. Each button gives one note on the push and a different note on the pull, the way a harmonica does, which is why Hohner’s accordion range describes the diatonic as having two notes per button. The instrument is built around specific keys, and the rows are named for them: the Hohner Corona II Classic is a three row box sold in G/C/F, F/B/Eb and E/A/D.

This is not a limitation that the player works around. It is the instrument. The bounce you hear in Cajun, Norteño and Irish playing comes partly from the bellows reversing to reach the next note, so the phrasing and the breathing of the music are built into the layout.

Push Pull: The Question That Decides Most of It

If you want one note per button regardless of bellows direction, you want a piano accordion or a chromatic button accordion. If you want the bisonoric feel, you want a diatonic box.

Everything else people argue about follows from this. Sight reading a piece of written music is straightforward on a unisonoric instrument because the note you read is the button you press. On a bisonoric instrument the same written note may need a different button depending on which way the bellows are going at that moment, which is why diatonic traditions lean on playing by ear and on notation written for the instrument rather than for the pitch.

Range for the Same Size Instrument

Buttons sit closer together than piano keys, and a button keyboard stacks its notes in rows rather than in one line. So for a given physical size, a chromatic button accordion reaches further up and down than a piano accordion does.

Put another way: if you want a wide range in an instrument you can carry and stand up with for a whole evening, buttons give you more of it per kilogram. If you want the widest possible range and do not mind the weight, that argument matters less.

Transposing: One Shape or Twelve

On a chromatic button accordion the fingering pattern for a scale or a chord is the same shape in every key. Move the shape up the keyboard and you have transposed. Nothing about the pattern changes.

On a piano accordion the pattern changes with the key, exactly as it does on a piano, because the black and white keys are not evenly spaced. Players who transpose constantly, which includes a lot of people accompanying singers, often name this as the single reason they moved to buttons.

On a diatonic box the question barely applies. You change key by picking up an instrument in a different key, or by using a different row.

Reading Printed Music

Most published accordion method books, and most sheet music sold as accordion music, assume a piano accordion. The right hand part is written on a treble staff that maps directly onto the keys.

That is a real convenience rather than a musical advantage. Chromatic button players read the same treble staff and work out their own fingering, and there is teaching material written for them. Diatonic players often work from tablature showing row and button number with push and pull marked, since that carries information the staff does not.

If you already play piano, the piano accordion right hand will feel familiar within minutes. Be aware that the familiarity stops at the right hand, and that the left hand and the bellows are the parts that actually take the time.

Where Each One Turns Up

These are conventions, not rules, and there are players breaking every one of them.

  • Diatonic button accordion: Cajun and zydeco, Norteño and Tejano, Quebecois, Irish traditional, English and Morris music, and a great deal of European village dance music.
  • Chromatic button accordion: French musette, Balkan and Russian repertoire, much of the European classical and competition world, and a lot of contemporary jazz playing.
  • Piano accordion: polka, American and British dance bands, klezmer, a large share of classical and jazz playing, and most school and community music programs.

If you are learning in order to play a particular music with other people, this list outranks every other consideration on this page. Turn up to an Irish session with a chromatic button accordion and you will be fine, but you will be working out for yourself what everyone else absorbed from the instrument itself.

Register Switches Are on Both

Accordions carry more than one set of reeds, and the switches above or beside the keyboard combine them. The American Accordionists’ Association guide counts eleven right hand switches built from combinations of four ranks of reeds, changing octave and timbre. A switch can drop the sound an octave, add an octave above, or bring in a second reed tuned very slightly away from the first to give the wavering tone heard in musette playing.

Piano accordions and chromatic button accordions both have these, and so do many diatonic boxes. So if someone tells you one type sounds brighter or fuller than the other, ask which registers were selected, because that difference is usually the switches rather than the keyboard.

Weight, Straps and Standing Up

An accordion hangs off your shoulders and sits against your chest. The right hand does not support it, which surprises pianists. A full size 120 bass instrument is a serious weight to stand and play with, and the way it is strapped matters as much as how heavy it is.

A back strap joining the two shoulder straps stops the instrument drifting apart from you and takes a surprising amount of strain out of a long session. If you intend to play standing, try the actual instrument standing up before buying, not seated in a shop chair. Smaller bass sizes exist precisely because many players would rather have 72 buttons they can carry than 120 they cannot.

What Actually Slows Beginners Down

Not the keyboard. Whichever right hand you choose, the two things that take longest are the bellows and the left hand.

  • The bellows are the breath of the instrument. Volume, attack and phrasing all come from them. Learning to change direction without a bump in the sound takes most people longer than learning where the notes are.
  • The left hand is played blind. You cannot see the bass buttons while playing, so you navigate by feel from the marked buttons. That is a new skill regardless of which instrument you picked.
  • Coordinating the two while the bellows move is the real work of the first year.

This is worth knowing before you agonize over the right hand choice, because the part people deliberate over longest is not the part that decides whether they stick with it.

Finding a Teacher and Finding an Instrument

Piano accordions are the easiest of the three to find secondhand in most English speaking countries, and the easiest to find a teacher for. Chromatic button accordions are common in continental Europe and thinner on the ground elsewhere. Diatonic boxes are easy to find wherever their music is played and harder to find where it is not.

Before buying anything, find out what is actually available near you and who teaches it. An instrument you can get serviced and lessons you can attend beat a theoretically better choice sitting unplayed.

Can You Switch Later

Yes, and the left hand comes with you. Stradella is Stradella. The bellows control, the breathing, the sense of how the instrument responds, all of that transfers.

What does not transfer is the right hand. Moving between a piano accordion and a chromatic button accordion means learning a new keyboard from the beginning, though you will be learning it as a musician rather than as a beginner, which is a very different experience. Moving to or from a diatonic box means changing how you think about the bellows, not only where you put your fingers.

Choosing

  1. Name the music first. If you are learning for a specific tradition, the tradition picks the instrument.
  2. Decide on push pull. Same note both directions, or not. This is the real fork in the road.
  3. Check what you can actually buy and learn on locally.
  4. If you already read piano music and want to use that, the piano accordion lets you start playing sooner.
  5. If you transpose a lot or want range without weight, look at a chromatic button accordion.
  6. Try all three before deciding if you possibly can. Thirty minutes with each one settles more than any amount of reading.

There is no better instrument here. There is the one that suits the music you want to play and the hands you already have.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it hard to play a button accordion?

No harder than any accordion, but which button accordion matters. A chromatic button accordion plays the same note whichever way the bellows move, so it behaves like a piano accordion with a different keyboard. A diatonic button accordion gives a different note on the push than on the pull, which takes more getting used to if you are coming from a keyboard instrument. In both cases the bellows and the left hand take longer to learn than the buttons do.

Which type of accordion is easier to learn?

For someone who already reads piano music, the piano accordion gets you playing soonest, because the right hand maps onto the keys you already know and most published method books are written for it. For someone starting from nothing, no type is clearly easier. A chromatic button accordion has one fingering shape per scale in every key, which is simpler than the piano keyboard once learned. The bigger factor is whether you can find a teacher and an instrument near you.

Is the accordion harder than the piano?

It is different rather than harder. The right hand of a piano accordion does roughly what a pianist already does. What is new is that you cannot see the left hand buttons while playing, so you navigate them by feel, and that the bellows control volume, attack and phrasing throughout. A pianist picking up an accordion usually finds the first week easy and the first year harder than expected.

What is the difference between an accordion and a piano accordion?

A piano accordion is a type of accordion. The word accordion covers the whole family of bellows driven free reed instruments with a keyboard or buttons on the right hand. Piano accordion means the ones with piano style keys. The main alternatives are the chromatic button accordion and the diatonic button accordion or melodeon.

News Reporter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *